Welcome
Downloads Home
Review Guidelines
Main site
Forums
Code of Conduct
Search

Advanced Search
Modpacks
Home
New Releases
New Reviews
New Comments
Top-Rated

Submit File
Browse Categories
New Files

Downloads Home » Modpacks » New Separatist Cannon

Download File Post Review Post Comment

New Separatist Cannon

Author File Description
Redfive --New Separatist Cannon--

The New Weapon Seen In Clone Wars 3D Serie Chapter 14 "Defenders Of The Peace"

Replaces:

[TF]Heavy Artillery

Includes:

-Graphics
-Player Colour
-Icon

Made By Redfive

*Fading Light Design*
AuthorComments & Reviews   ( All | Comments Only | Reviews Only )
JudicialT
Rating
2.0
Rating: 2
Wow. At first, It looked pretty good. However, something seemed amiss. There was a sudden change in quality in certain areas, and then it occurred to me... the artillery looked just like a TF tank with the turret removed and replaced by a TF artillery gun, then repainted. Then there were those little fins you just tacked on to the back that dragged down the rest of the mod. I mean, it works, but it looks like something a bunch of guys just blaged together with spare parts- you could have at least matched all the colors together.

Additional Comments:
N/A
Selur JudicialT, the Separatist Cannon in the Clone Wars Series does not have matching colors. You shouldn't give a 2.0 rating for it accurately portraying the unit.
JudicialT I didn't take off for the colors, actually, as I knew the colors didn't match in the show either. However, the mod didn't match the actual vehicle's color either; I rated low for lack of realism and originality. The mod would've been much better if at least the cannon itself was made from scratch.

However, I did give a two for effort. And hell, it works. No frame problems and it gets the job done, but not quite an adequate replacement for the original unit and not quite the same unit as the show's, therefore rendering it basically useless.
Selur Who cares if it wasn't "made from scratch". Cut and paste modding has been around for years. Imho, since "it works" and there are no problems with the frames itself, it is worthy of a perfect quality (5/5). Even if it is completely useless, it should still get at a 3.0 rating.

Just my two cents.

Post Review Post Comment

HGDL v0.8.0

Login
Forum Username:


Password:




Create a new account
Forgot password?
Rating
2.0
Statistics
Downloads:662
Favorites: [Who?]1
Size:29.61 KB
Added:04/05/09